FMC FSI photodetection module 8ch design review
General information
Typically, hardware designs are reviewed more than once and at different stages (schematics, layout). Each review is performed as follows:
- Reviewers provide feedback by
- Creating issues and labeling them using Issues label name (e.g. "pcb-review-1", see table below). Please, check already submitted issues before submitting yours to avoid repeating the same feedback (feel free to add to the existing issue). Creating issues requires account on ohwr.org, if you do have yet an account, please contact Maciej Lipinski providing the username you would like to have.
OR - Sending your feedback by email to Maciej Lipinski.
- Creating issues and labeling them using Issues label name (e.g. "pcb-review-1", see table below). Please, check already submitted issues before submitting yours to avoid repeating the same feedback (feel free to add to the existing issue). Creating issues requires account on ohwr.org, if you do have yet an account, please contact Maciej Lipinski providing the username you would like to have.
- Collection of review feedback finishes by deadline (see the table below), designers are welcome to reply to feedback as soon as it is submitted (no need to wait to the deadline) - it is appreciated that he designers monitors new issues regularly.
- Ideally, most of the discussion between reviewers and designers happens via issues.
- If needed, a meeting will be organised to summarized the most important resolved issues and handle outstanding issues.
When reviewing, please refer to Schematics design review checklist.
Reviews
Date | Design files | Issues label name | Comments | Deadline | Status | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 2022-07 | schematics and layout v2.0(zip, pdf) | pcb-review-1 | end of day 2022-07-19 | completed | |
2 | 2022-08 | schematics and layout v2.1 (tar, pdf) | pcb-review-2 | completed |
Notes for review 1:
The design still needs to be updated for mechanical integration of
- clips to hold EMC shielding
- holes to attach the fiber spool holder